Home · Tesla

Tesla Model S: which year should you buy?

Across the 2012 to 2026 model years, the public record is strongest on the 2024 (86/100). Every year below is scored on its own NHTSA complaint and recall history. Pick the year, not just the nameplate.

Best years to target

2024 86 · 2020 83 · 2023 80

Every model year, scored

Same math for every year (how we score). A neutral Unproven or Too New stamp means too few owner reports are on file to affirm the year, not that it’s clean.

202664/100
Too New

3 complaints · 0 recalls

202564/100
Unproven

6 complaints · 0 recalls

202486/100
Buybest year

38 complaints · 0 recalls

202380/100
Buy

108 complaints · 0 recalls

202264/100
Caution

136 complaints · 20 recalls

202157/100
Caution

175 complaints · 24 recalls

202083/100
Buy

80 complaints · 0 recalls

201456/100
Caution

365 complaints · 9 recalls

201353/100
Caution

459 complaints · 11 recalls

201264/100
Caution

59 complaints · 8 recalls

Zeroing in on the 2024?

The full year-by-year verdict is free. When you’re ready to inspect and negotiate one specific car, the Full Report turns the 2024 Tesla Model S’s complaint breakdown and recall list into an inspection-ready, shareable PDF.

Recalls, complaint breakdown & inspection checklist, all in a shareable PDF

Cross-shopping a different nameplate? Compare the 2026 Tesla Model S head-to-head →

The fine print: each year’s verdict is computed from public NHTSA complaint and recall records for the Tesla Model S as a model, not for any individual car. A well-kept example of a weaker year can outlast a neglected strong one. Informational only, so always get a professional pre-purchase inspection.